October Office Hours FAQs: Binary Options, Reverse Splits and Ratio Spreads
All or nothing? Calls or shares? Our October Office Hours tackled these questions and more — here’s a look at what came up.
Binary Options: All or Nothing
How is a binary option different from a regular call or put?
A regular option pays more the farther the stock moves past the strike. A binary option does not. It pays a fixed amount if a set condition is met at expiration, and nothing if it isn’t. Say a binary call is trading $40 and will pay $100 if an index closes above 670 on Friday. The buyer risks $40 to make $60, and that payout stays fixed no matter how far the index finishes above 670. In other words, before expiration, the contract’s price reflects the market’s estimate of the probability that it finishes at or above that level.
Dividends and Reverse Splits
Can a deep in-the-money call stand in for owning the stock?
It can act a lot like stock in terms of Delta, but it isn’t stock. A call holder is not a shareholder of record, so only people who own the shares are paid a dividend.
Spreads, Implied Volatility and Time Decay
When implied volatility jumps, do the two legs of a spread move in opposite directions?
No. When implied volatility rises, both options rise in price. When it falls, both fall. What flips is the effect on profit and loss In a long 50-55 call spread, the trader is long the 50 call and short the 55 call, , so an increase in the value of the 50 call adds to the position’s value, while an increase in the value of the 55 call reduces it. The two options also have different Vega, meaning they react by different amounts. The gains and losses largely offset, so the spread itself moves much less than a single option would.
Why does a spread with only a few days left lose money so quickly?
Options near the money and close to expiration are very sensitive to moves in the stock price, but they also lose value quickly. At-the-money and out-of-the-money options are made up entirely of extrinsic value, which decays rapidly. With seven days left, an option has Theta working against it, and there’s little time for a bad move to reverse.
Ratio Spreads and Stock Repair
How does a ratio spread lower the break-even on a stock that has fallen?
Say a trader bought stock at $80 and it now trades at $60. In a 1-by-2 call ratio spread, the trader buys one at-the-money 60 call and sells two out-of-the-money 70 calls. As the stock rises from 60 toward 70, both the shares and the long call gain value, so the position recovers about twice as fast. At 70, those gains make up the $20 loss, and the short calls are still worthless, so the new break-even is near the short strike. Above 70, the two short calls offset further gains and cap the profit potential. Whether the trade is done for a credit or a debit shifts the break-even slightly lower or higher.
How are the short strikes chosen?
Buying one at-the-money call, then sell two calls at a strike above it, typically half the loss on the stock. For example a trader bought stock at $80, and it now trades at $60. To reset breakeven, the trader buys the $60 call and sells two $70 calls. As the stock rises from $60 to $70, the shares and the long call each gain $10, which offsets the $20 loss, and $70 is the new break-even point. Above 70, the two short calls offset further gains and cap the profit.
Further, the new break-even at $70 holds when the spread is done for even money. A net credit lowers it slightly, and a net debit raises it.
Does margin buying power apply when buying options?
Not the way it does for stock. Stock buyers can generally borrow part of the cost and pay interest on it, but option buyers typically pay the full premium with their own money. Margin applies when a trader sells uncovered options, and some spreads carry collateral requirements too. A short naked call theoretically has unlimited risk, so the broker requires collateral and may issue a margin call as the stock rises. Buying power shows what a broker allows, not how much risk is wise. Requirements vary by broker, so check with yours.
What’s an acceptable risk-reward ratio on a credit spread?
There’s no single answer. OIC instructors don’t give advice, and what suits one trader may not suit another.
Pricing Models: Binomial vs. Black-Scholes
Which is more accurate, the binomial model or Black-Scholes?
They fit different uses. Black-Scholes prices European-style options, which can only be exercised at expiration. A binomial model, often Cox-Ross-Rubinstein, can also handle early exercise, which matters for American-style options. For European-style options, a binomial model with enough steps gives nearly the same price as Black-Scholes. The OIC options calculator, found under tools at OptionsEducation.org, works for both styles.
